Editorial Assessment

 

What it is

An Editorial Assessment, sometimes called a manuscript evaluation or a manuscript critique, takes a look at story-level elements, including overall plot and pacing, characterization, and world building. The biggest difference between this and Developmental Editing, however, is the way in which my findings are presented to the author. An Editorial Assessment includes an editorial letter, but not in-line manuscript edits. This is typically done before any other editing services, when the author isn’t sure the plot, characterization, or world building works at all. I’ll take a look at the way the scenes and chapters fit together, always analyzing your story with the reader in mind. I’ll also focus heavily on goal, motivation, and conflict for your characters, as well as considerations for genre or target audience. This is typically a quicker and less expensive option than Developmental Editing, as it’s not as comprehensive.

Who it’s for

  • Authors who have finished at least one draft of their manuscript on their own

  • Authors who have not had any other professional editing services done on this particular manuscript

  • Authors who are comfortable working primarily on their own, with less instruction from the editor

  • Authors who are stuck with a particular plot point and need some help nudging the plot along

  • Authors who have been through the professional editing process at least once before, on a different manuscript

  • Authors who are interested in self-publishing or traditional publishing

 

What’s included

  • A long-form editorial letter that includes my thoughts about the story as a whole, as well as my suggestions for bringing it to the next level. Typically runs from 3 to 10 pages.

  • Positive feedback and suggestions

  • My working style guide that includes a dictionary of spelling and grammar choices that were made, short character profiles, timeline references, location profiles, brief summaries of each chapter and scene, and more

  • Ongoing email support to answer questions and offer clarify after project is done, as necessary

  • Optional: Synopsis Review

  • Optional: Query Letter Review

What’s not included

  • In-line edits or comments in the manuscript itself

  • Copy & Line Editing or Proofreading

  • Work on partial manuscripts

  • Non-fiction fact checking and citation verification

  • Ghostwriting

  • Formatting and layout

  • Subject expertise

  • Translating

  • Editing in any languages other than English

  • Video or voice calls


Interested in getting a quote?

Click the link below to head to my Contact page.
Fill out the form with as much information as you can, and I’ll get back to you within 48 hours!


Still have a question?

  • Not necessarily! Editorial Assessments are most helpful in situations where an author is stuck on a particular plot point, can’t figure out how to make something work, or just needs another set of eyes on their manuscript. Because I go into less detail in an Editorial Assessment, I recommend this for authors who are confident in their abilities to interpret my suggestions and revise largely on their own.

    I truly believe that every manuscript will benefit from developmental edits. This process is a chance for me to really deep dive into your story and look at it the way your reader will. It’s always helpful to get an impartial look at your novel to determine weak points, inconsistencies, errors, and more.

  • Ask yourself these questions:

    • Is your novel as done as it can be?

    • Have you already completed at least one draft of your novel?

    If you answered “Yes” to both of these questions, you’re likely ready for an Editorial Assessment. Still not sure? Request a quote and I’ll assess your manuscript’s readiness.

  • When I receive your quote request, I’ll take a look at your sample and assess whether you’re ready for an Editorial Assessment. If it looks like we’ll be a good fit, I’ll put together my offer, as well as a sample edit. If you agree that we’re a good match, you’ll accept my offer and we’ll get you on my schedule.

    Once the project has officially started and you’ve sent me your final manuscript, I deep dive into it. During this time, you likely won’t hear from me much, as I’m saving all my comments and suggestions for the editorial letter. I don’t offer mid-project updates or check-ins because your job is not to think about the manuscript or work on it in any way. The goal is for you to take a breather and feel fresh when you have my edits in hand.

    When I’m done editing, I’ll send everything back to you, then it’s in your hands. I’m happy to answer questions or clarify my thoughts after I’m done editing, but you are responsible for the actual revisions.

  • An Editorial Assessment can take anywhere from one weeks to four weeks depending on the length of your novel. 20,000-word novellas that are very clean might only need one week, while 150,000-word novels that are on the rough side might need four weeks. I’ll offer you a turnaround time based on your manuscript and my schedule availability with my quote.

  • The cost of an Editorial Assessment varies based on length of your novel. A 20,000-word novella that is very clean might start at $0.01/word, while a 150,000-word novel that is on the rough side might start at $0.025/word. Each quote is tailored to your manuscript.

  • Absolutely! Every quote comes with a FREE short sample edit so you can better see what my edits will look like. This is a great way to know if we’ll be a good fit.

  • An editorial letter is a long-form piece where I make suggestions, explain my thoughts, and comment on your work as a whole. This allows me to draw parallels between different scenes, point out inconsistencies across the entire novel, explain where changes might be necessary, and offer you my overall thoughts. These letters generally range between 3 and 15 pages.

  • A style sheet is the document that I use while editing to keep track of different elements of your novel. It includes the following:

    • A dictionary of spelling choices and proper nouns

    • Short character profiles and descriptions

    • Timeline references

    • Location profiles

    • A list of grammatical choices

    Style sheets help me, as the editor, make consistent choices throughout your novel, and they can be helpful to you, as the author, too! They might shed light on character description inconsistencies (for instance, if she’s a brunette on page 73 but a redhead on page 217), or on main characters that only have one physical description in the whole novel (which is more common than you might think!). Maybe you spelled your character’s name a few different ways, or your town’s name is punctuated differently throughout. A style sheet will reveal all!

    Style sheets are also helpful across a series, as I can make sure that all elements stay consistent throughout each manuscript.

  • Actually, no! Part of my quoting process involves taking a look at your sample edit and determining whether you’re ready for developmental editing. If I think a different level of editing would be more beneficial to you, I’ll offer that instead, or if I think that you need to keep working on the manuscript before bringing in an editor, I’ll let you know first. It’s not beneficial to you OR me to work on a manuscript that’s not ready for editing.

  • That’s totally okay! My suggestions are just that—my own suggestions. At the end of the day, this is YOUR story, and you get to make the choices. I’ll do my best to explain WHY I suggest each change, however, so you can make an informed decision.


Ready for that quote now?

Click the link below to head to my Contact page.
Fill out the form with as much information as you can, and I’ll get back to you within 48 hours!